Eletiofe The Premier League has a VAR crisis. The NFL...

The Premier League has a VAR crisis. The NFL has a solution

-

- Advertisment -

VAR, in theory, sounded great. It really did. ” data-reactid=”16″ type=”text”>VAR, in theory, sounded great. It really did. 

VAR is not great. It’s harming the sport. Injecting itself unnecessarily to suck away joy. Changing outcomes that literally nobody felt needed to change.” data-reactid=”17″ type=”text”>But a few years after soccer’s first widespread video review system debuted, it has become clear that VAR is not great. It’s harming the sport. Injecting itself unnecessarily to suck away joy. Changing outcomes that literally nobody felt needed to change.

turned a brilliant Merseyside Derby into a postgame moan-fest. Jordan Henderson won the match for Liverpool. Then he didn’t, because apparently Sadio Mane’s shoulder was one inch too far forward in the buildup to the goal.” data-reactid=”22″ type=”text”>On Saturday, it turned a brilliant Merseyside Derby into a postgame moan-fest. Jordan Henderson won the match for Liverpool. Then he didn’t, because apparently Sadio Mane’s shoulder was one inch too far forward in the buildup to the goal.

(Screenshot: NBC Sports)

marginal, previously undetectable errors-that-aren’t-really-errors, like the phantom offside that disallowed Wolves’ equalizer against Liverpool last year …” data-reactid=”34″ type=”text”>The Video Assistant Referee system has overstepped its bounds. It was put in place to correct “clear and obvious errors,” which it does. It has also reversed marginal, previously undetectable errors-that-aren’t-really-errors, like the phantom offside that disallowed Wolves’ equalizer against Liverpool last year

Wolves’ equalizer against Liverpool was disallowed by VAR for this “offside” in the buildup. (Screenshot: NBC Sports)

… and the eerily similar call that disallowed Henderson’s winner against this year.

offsides and handballs that are anything but “clear and obvious.” It’s the hesitation that now accompanies every goal because of them. It’s the unspoken fear that ecstatic celebrations will, two minutes later, seem embarrassing; that the most instantaneous and genuine of emotions can be undone.” data-reactid=”47″ type=”text”>VAR, like so many other great ideas, came bearing unintended consequences. The issue isn’t just the offsides and handballs that are anything but “clear and obvious.” It’s the hesitation that now accompanies every goal because of them. It’s the unspoken fear that ecstatic celebrations will, two minutes later, seem embarrassing; that the most instantaneous and genuine of emotions can be undone.

Something has to change. The difficult part is figuring out what, and how. Because the simple solutions also bear unintended consequences. VAR, therefore, needs an overhaul.

The first issue with Saturday’s Liverpool-Everton decision is that it’s unclear whether Mane was actually offside. Because, for all the technology that enables VAR, it still requires a human to make a very subjective and difficult decision: Where, underneath Mane’s sleeve, does his arm – which is irrelevant for offside purposes – end and his shoulder begin?

The video assistant isn’t some expert on Mane’s anatomy. He doesn’t have X-ray images at his disposal. Offside is supposedly factually, which is why decisions don’t have to be “clearly and obviously” wrong to be overturned. But there’s significant room for human error here. Enough that an incorrectly-drawn line could ruin a perfectly good goal.

1. How are we trusting a human to look at a screen and point to the exact spot that Sadio Mane’s shoulder becomes his arm?

2. How are we picking out the exact moment when Thiago plays the ball? (There isn’t one exact moment)

3. How to fix VAR: https://t.co/9pJjhqaW3w pic.twitter.com/WQ04vLcOCU

— Henry Bushnell (@HenryBushnell) October 17, 2020

One solution would be to account for that margin of error. Tweak the rule so that there must be, say, three inches between the attacking line and defensive line to overturn a call.

The problem with any fix specifically targeting offside decisions, however, is that line-drawing is necessary no matter the law. Another common proposal is that offside should require “daylight” between infringing attacker and last defender. But who decides what constitutes “daylight”?

No matter where you draw the line, there are imperfections and marginal decisions that must be made. There would be fury on the margins of a three-inch buffer, just like there is fury with no buffer.

The solution is to leave the laws intact, and devise a different system for deciding what’s “clear and obvious.”

Fortunately, the NFL has already devised that system. It’s called the coaches challenge system. It takes responsibility away from off-site video assistants and hands it to the aggrieved teams themselves. Because who better to decide what’s “clear and obvious” than the managers who believe they’ve been clearly and obviously wronged?

Here, in short, is how and why a challenge system would work in soccer:

This will significantly reduce the amount of time spent waiting on VARs, not only because it introduces a maximum of four reviews per game, but because it forces coaches to be prudent rather than reckless with their challenges. They can’t just reflexively call for a review of a first-half goal, because if they’re wrong, they have no recourse for the second-half decision that is clearly and obviously wrong.

• The mechanics of the challenge: Coaches trigger a review by going to the fourth official in that 10-second window. If there’s a worry that coaches don’t have proper vantage points to detect clear and obvious errors in real time, allow them to communicate, via headset or earpiece, with an assistant watching a live video feed. Also, give the captain challenge power. Just as the manager can go to the fourth official, the captain can go to the on-field referee.” data-reactid=”69″ type=”text”>• The mechanics of the challenge: Coaches trigger a review by going to the fourth official in that 10-second window. If there’s a worry that coaches don’t have proper vantage points to detect clear and obvious errors in real time, allow them to communicate, via headset or earpiece, with an assistant watching a live video feed. Also, give the captain challenge power. Just as the manager can go to the fourth official, the captain can go to the on-field referee.

At first, this sounds dangerous … but the challenge system remains the great regulator. Coaches would never challenge a foul at midfield in the first half, no matter how clearly and obviously wrong the call is. But if there’s a questionable tackle just outside the box in the 90th minute, they should be able to challenge it. It’s up to them to decide not only what is “clear and obvious,” but what is impactful enough in the grander scheme of the game.

• Time limits on reviews: Once a review begins, the referee jogs over to a pitchside monitor. Once he gets there, he and the Video Assistant Referee have 60 seconds to make a decision. If the evidence they see in those 60 seconds convinces them the call on the field was wrong, they overturn it. If not, they leave it as is.” data-reactid=”73″ type=”text”>• Time limits on reviews: Once a review begins, the referee jogs over to a pitchside monitor. Once he gets there, he and the Video Assistant Referee have 60 seconds to make a decision. If the evidence they see in those 60 seconds convinces them the call on the field was wrong, they overturn it. If not, they leave it as is.

The time limit essentially serves as the “clear and obvious” threshold. If offside is in question, and intricate lines from grass to shoulder are necessary because nothing about the play was “clear and obvious,” the refs won’t have enough time for definitive conclusions.

What a challenge system would look like in practice

Jordan Pickford clattered into Virgil van Dijk and probably should have been sent off. There was no call on the field. If Jurgen Klopp immediately felt there should have been, he could have used a challenge. It probably would have been successful. Pickford would have been shown a red card, and Klopp would have been awarded a second challenge to use at some point throughout the rest of the game.” data-reactid=”76″ type=”text”>Let’s retrospectively consider Saturday’s Merseyside Derby as a test case. The first controversial incident came in the first half, when Jordan Pickford clattered into Virgil van Dijk and probably should have been sent off. There was no call on the field. If Jurgen Klopp immediately felt there should have been, he could have used a challenge. It probably would have been successful. Pickford would have been shown a red card, and Klopp would have been awarded a second challenge to use at some point throughout the rest of the game.

Or perhaps Klopp doesn’t challenge the Pickford-van Dijk incident, and the game plays out as it did in reality.

In the second half, Everton manager Carlo Ancelotti could have challenged a 59th-minute incident when Richarlison appeared to be tugged ever so slightly by Trent Alexander-Arnold while pursuing a cross. He also could have challenged Richarlison’s 90th-minute red card, which Everton players initially protested. Ancelotti might have been right about the first. He would have been wrong about the second. He wouldn’t have had a challenge remaining to contest Henderson’s winner. And absolutely nobody would be complaining that Mane was offside.

The system is far from perfect. There will be instances, inevitably, when a late call costs a team points because a coach, having exhausted his or her challenges, can do nothing about it. But that happens far more often without VAR. And more often than not, those coaches would only have themselves to blame for a faulty or less significant challenge earlier in the game.

The challenge system is the best of both worlds. It retains the flow of the game. It gets rid of the looming, inescapable uncertainty that currently pollutes every key moment of every game. But it still corrects the blatant errors – as long as coaches challenge responsibly.

  • Keyser: Controversial Astros force Game 7 the old-fashioned way

  • Brown: Smith keeps Dodgers alive in NLCS by winning tiny margins

  • NFL Week 6 picks: Packers’ test vs. Buccaneers should tell us a lot

  • Watch ‘Fantasy Football Live’ Sunday morning at 11:30 a.m. ET

  • Previous articleLiverpool denied late win against Everton because of VAR’s incompetence (video)
    Next articleChristian Pulisic makes first start of season but can’t save leaky Chelsea against Southampton (video)

    Latest news

    The Looted COVID-19 Palliatives Were Not Hoarded But Kept For Vulnerable People – NGF

    The Nigeria Governors’ Forum (NGF) has cleared the air on discovered COVID-19 palliatives which were looted across the country.The...

    #EndSARS: You’re Daydreamer, 2023 Presidency Not For Sale – Bamgbose Warns Tinubu

    Bola Tinubu The National leader of the All Progressives Congress, Bola Tinubu has been asked to abandon his ambition to...

    US Court Jails Nigerian Fraudster for Scamming Victims Over $1,869,419 (Photo)

    Nosa Onaghise The US Justice Department has released a statement after convicting a Nigerian fraudster, Nosa Onaghise. It was gathered that...

    #EndSARS Shooting: Buhari’s Minister, Fashola Discovers Hidden Camera at Lekki Toll Gate (Video)

    Fashola discovers hidden camera at Lekki toll gate A camera hidden at the Lekki toll gate has been discovered by Babatunde...
    - Advertisement -

    Lekki Shooting: “Nigerian State Has Blood On Its Hands” – Pastor Bakare Warns Buhari

    Pastor Bakare Pastor Tunde Bakare has sent a warning to President Muhammadu Buhari following the shooting of peaceful #EndSARS protesters...

    Brazilian soccer star Ronaldinho tests positive for COVID-19

    Former Brazilian soccer star Ronaldinho contracted COVID-19, though is asymptomatic, he announced on Instagram on Sunday. The former Brazil and...

    Must read

    The Looted COVID-19 Palliatives Were Not Hoarded But Kept For Vulnerable People – NGF

    The Nigeria Governors’ Forum (NGF) has cleared the air...

    #EndSARS: You’re Daydreamer, 2023 Presidency Not For Sale – Bamgbose Warns Tinubu

    Bola Tinubu The National leader of the All Progressives Congress,...
    - Advertisement -

    You might also likeRELATED
    Recommended to you